It’s Time to Return to Text-Based Ad Creatives

share

I just got back from New York City. Not a work trip, but while I was there, I caught myself looking with an analytical eye at all the ads on the subway system (almost missing my stop once or twice), as well as the digital billboards of Midtown Manhattan, and everywhere in between.

The ads, of course, varied in terms of their strength. I saw personal injury lawyer creatives that would have been scrapped at the first brainstorm session here at Fortress, among countless other ones that I can’t recall because there was nothing worth recalling about them.

That said, I did see some TRULY clever ads that were run by the New York City transit system itself. One ad stood out.

It simply said, “Don’t be someone’s subway story. Courtesy counts.” These ads were everywhere, including on the boards within the train cars that can support dynamic video ads.

Marketing is about empathy, and I thought it was a beautiful encapsulation of how an entity like the New York City subway system can show empathy to the people who spend their money riding it. If we all approached our ad creatives with that same level of “realness” from business to consumer, I think it would pay major dividends. People want their problems solved, and surely not sugarcoated. A subway rider who grows tired of people taking loud phone calls, moving from car to car, or otherwise being a nuisance, will eventually become someone who opts for rideshare or a bike and doesn’t use the system anymore. So, these ads, with their messaging and their prevalence, are hammering home a message that shows they give a you-know-what about the customer’s experiences.

Determining the ROI for this ad campaign might be difficult, and that’s okay.

The larger point I want to make here is that using text-only ad creatives can be just as effective as a graphic or a video, if not more, when done right.

Here’s why. Text-based ads don’t just communicate a message—they invite interaction. Whether it’s a clever headline, a pointed reminder like the subway system’s campaign, or a challenge to the reader’s assumptions, they force the audience to actively engage with the message. Unlike video or flashy graphics, which can sometimes fade into the background of overstimulation, a well-crafted line of text demands attention and thought.

Text-based ads also embody an element of trust. They assume the reader has the patience, intelligence, and willingness to absorb what’s being said. This is a radical idea in an era of shrinking attention spans, but it’s one that can resonate deeply when the right words are used. Brands that embrace this approach show confidence—not just in their message, but in their audience.

So, let’s stop assuming no one reads. People read when it matters to them. They read when the content is relevant, personal, and impactful. That ad resonated because it spoke directly to the frustrations of subway riders, acknowledging a shared experience without trying to dress it up.

As marketers, we can take a page from this playbook. Words have power. Let’s use them wisely.

More From The Vault

SENIOR Designer

Apply by filling out the form and someone will be in touch with you.

    Attach Files (Resume, Portfolio etc.)

    MAKE YOUR MOVE.

    Fill out the form, tell us about your project, and we'll reach out to you.

      Services

      STAY IN THE LOOP

      Follow our journey as we continue to help shape and transform brands.

      [job_description_popup]

      SENIOR designer

      Full Job Description

      Fortress is a fast-growing digital marketing and branding agency headquartered in Chicago that has worked with clients ranging from global corporations like Nike, Jordan, All-State, Acura, athletes, and celebrities like Kevin Hart, Steph Curry, prestigious universities, startups, and everyone in between. We believe in putting family first, being team players, staying humble, and being obsessed with our clients’ success. We provide a unique and energetic culture that fosters creativity and camaraderie.

      We’re currently seeking a full-time Senior Designer to join the team and work out of our Chicago, IL office. The right person for this position sees the bigger picture while remaining passionate about the details.

      You’re knowledgeable and skilled in Web, Branding, large-scale marketing campaigns, and more. You’re a jack of all trades in creative software, but you also have a passion for design beyond the screen. You understand that great design is in the nuance—that subtle cultural references should be woven into the things you create and every project should be approached with the end-user at the center of it. You love working on a team with diverse perspectives and you’re willing to learn from as well as build up those around you. At the core, you’re a problem solver with a knack for making things look good.

      WHAT YOU’LL DO

      • Contribute to various projects in web, brand identity, and print across multiple industries
      • Collaborate and ideate with the design and marketing teams, while also giving and receiving feedback on designs
      • Create presentations and asset kits to be delivered to team members, clients, and partners
      • Present your creatives to clients with the ability to back up your ideas, while also being open to new ideas and critiques

      WHAT YOU’LL BRING

      • 3-5 years of experience working in design and digital marketing
      • A strong portfolio with a diverse array of work and a strong foundation in basic design principles (typography, layout, color, UX/UI)
      • Problem-solving and storytelling abilities
      • Multi-tasking and prioritization skills
      • Experience working in Adobe CC and Figma
      • 3D, Animation, Video Editing, and Photography is a plus
      • A collaborative mindset
      • A good sense of your own design and visual style
      • Attention to detail
      • A passion for growth and a never-ending curiosity

      Job Type: Full-time

      Benefits:

      • 401(k)
      • 401(k) matching
      • Dental insurance
      • Flexible schedule
      • Health insurance
      • Paid time off
      • Professional development assistance
      • Vision insurance

      Schedule:

      • 8-hour shift
      • Monday to Friday
      • Weekend availability

      Supplemental Pay:

      • Bonus pay
      • Commission pay

      Ability to commute/relocate:

      • Chicago, IL 60642: Reliably commute or planning to relocate before starting work (Required)

      Experience:

      • Graphic design: 6 years (Required)
      • Web design: 4 years (Required)

      SENIOR DIGITAL STRATEGIST

      Apply by filling out the form and someone will be in touch with you.

        Attach Files (Resume, Portfolio etc.)

        CONFIRMATION

        WE ARE WHAT MAKES FORTRESS DIFFERENT.

        Someone from our team will reach out to you about your project soon.